Nail Polish Remover vs Acetone 2021 【All Pros & Cons】

Nail Polish Remover vs Acetone

Nail polish has become an essential part of the fashion industry lately, and various nail enamel trends are being introduced regularly. With all the hype, the fashion industry has recognized the whole nail industry separately, contributing to various nail art styles, including acrylics, shellac, etc.

Also, these nail enamels help the hands look more attractive and younger, along with helping the manicure last longer. These reasons might also be the reason behind the increasing fame of nail enamels and nail art. People have started to build nail salons completely dedicated to just nail services, and customers do visit them regularly, making them successful.

It is quite obvious that if you have applied a particular nail enamel, you might want to take it off after a while. Maybe for changing the color or design or even when the old one starts to chip off. So, as easy as it is to apply a nail enamel, it can sometimes be tough to remove it. Most nail enamels are stubborn and can consume your stamina while trying to get rid of them.

Read about Best LED Light for Gel Nails

Nail Polish Removing Products:

With the popularity of the nail industry, certain ways have also been introduced to get rid of nail paint. The most effective way is to use acetone for removing the nail enamel. Along with that, nail polish removers also introduce either acetone nail polish remover or non-acetone nail polish remover.

It is also important to know that whatever product you used, make sure to use nail strengthening and nail moisturizing products afterward. As all of the chemicals somehow tend to provide little or more damage to your nails to deal with the damage, take care of your nails. But all of these products come with their pros and cons.
Now, we will discuss both acetone and nail polish removers in detail.

Acetone/Acetone Nail Paint Remover:

Acetone is also recognized as propanone and is a colorless and flammable liquid/solvent. This solvent is majorly used in plastic manufacturing industries, household products, and cosmetics and personal care products.
Nail polish removers such as Acetone dissolve the nail polish and pull it off the nail plate surface. The top layer of nail polish contains plasticizers, film. Using acetone or acetone nail polish remover is extremely easy. You just have to pour a good amount of the solvent or remover onto a cotton pad and rub it off your nails.

A very commonly asked question is that is nail polish remover pure acetone. Well, the answer to that question is that it is not pure acetone and has some solvent ratios to improve the efficiency of the product. Moreover, what is the difference between acetone and pure acetone? Well, acetone has a certain amount or ratio of acetone, while pure acetone is solely acetone, also known as propanone.

Let’s discuss the pros and cons of acetone;

Pros:

  • Acetone is declared the fastest way to remove nail polish with its effective solvent properties.
  • It is effective for thick and stubborn nail polish layers like glitters, marbles, and shellac manicures.
  • It is time-saving, requires less effort as well as is the most effective.

Cons:

  • It is somehow damaging to the nails and cuticles.
  • The dangers of acetone nail polish remover include dehydration of nails and cuticles along with dry and brittle nails.
  • It also affects cuticles making them dry, red, flaky, and irritated.

Frequent use of acetone on nails can cause the whiteness of cuticles just after the removal of nail polish and other skin problems around the nails.
Although acetone nail polish removers are known for the damage they cause to your nails and cuticles, they are still the most effective nail polish removers in the market. Also, their damage is no big concern, while other concerns are still on top of the list, including poor salon hygiene, allergic salon dermatitis, and UV lamps.
Till all these concerns are resolved, acetone still is in the back, and professionals will continue to use it. And as long as you are taking good care of your nails, there is no need to worry about it.

Learn about Best Nail Art Brushes & Sets

Non-Acetone Nail Paint Remover:

The nail polish remover ingredients can differ from company to company, yet some nail polish remover chemicals remain. Mostly a nail paint remover contains effective solvents, oils, and some scents.
On the contrary to acetone nail remover, non-acetone nail polish removers contain alternative solvents, including ethyl acetate, isopropyl alcohol, butyl acetate, petroleum, etc. Moreover, they possess certain moisturizing elements such as aloe Vera and glycerin that help reduce the after-drying effect of the solvent.
Other than the chemical removers, natural removers are containing natural oils extracted from plants and scents.
You just have to take a good amount of your non-acetone nail polish remover or a cotton pad soaked in it to get rid of your enamel. It can be time-consuming as all of the solvents mentioned above are not as fast and effective as acetone.

Pros:

  • A non-acetone nail polish remover is very gentle on your nails and skin, causing the least damage.
  • It works by dissolving plastics, glues, and pigmented colors off from the nails without compromising the health of your nails and skin.
  • It helps you maintain the moisture of your nails and cuticles.

Cons:

  • It is not as effective as concentrated acetone or acetone nail polish remover.
  • It might be time-consuming and can take at least twenty minutes of continuous rubbing.
  • Extensive rubbing required in the case of non-acetone nail polish removers can also cause damage to the nails.

Read about Best Electric Nail Files UK

Comparison Between Acetone & Non-Acetone Nail Polish Remover:

CharacteristicsAcetoneNail polish Remover
DefinitionIs a volatile, flammable and colorless liquid that is miscible with waterIs an organic solvent that may include coloring, scents, oils, and solvents
ComponentsIs a component used in nail polish removersMay contain different types of solvents.
Miscibility with waterIs miscible with waterMay not be miscible with water, depending on the components used
UsesIs used is widely used as a solvent in many industries such as pharmaceutical, beauty, and domestic industriesIs only used in the beauty industry
As we have discussed both acetone and non-acetone nail polish removers in detail, we can now easily distinguish between them and analyze the differences while concluding the discussion.

  • The main difference between both of the nail polish removing products is in their composition. Acetone can also be used in a concentrated form for the purpose, along with the acetone-based nail polish remover has acetone as its major component. While in non-acetone nail polish remover, acetone is lacking and is replaced by certain other solvents.
  • Using acetone or acetone-based product saves a lot of time and effort as it is a very fast solvent. At the same time, non-acetone nail polish remover is not as effective and consumes more time, precisely twenty minutes of rubbing the product on your nails.
  • Moreover, acetone has proven the most effective product, while non-acetone product is not as effective.
  • Acetone gives a little edge to a non-acetone nail polish remover because it causes lesser damage to the nails and restores moisture. Due to its concentrated form being used, acetone tends to damage the nails and cuticles while taking in all the moisture.
  • A non-acetone nail polish remover has proved more effective for lighter colors and sensitive skins. At the same time, acetone does wonders for dark colors and stubborn techniques like shellac manicure, acrylics, and glitters.
  • Also, the price of one nail polish remover might differ from the other and is an important fact to consider while purchasing as one might not want to go too heavy on his/her pocket with a nail polish remover.
  • An acetone-based nail polish remover quality is much better than that of a non-acetone nail polish remover because of its high effectiveness and convenient use.

More on: Best Electric Nail Files

Concluding the Discussion:

Nail Polish Remover vs Acetone

Both of the nail polish removers are colorless and have a cooling effect. The only difference is the effectiveness of one product over the other. No doubt acetone or acetone-based nail polish remover works roughly on your nails, sucking in all the moisture and making them dry, weak, and brittle. On the other hand, the non-acetone nail polish removers are very gentle on your nails and skin. Still, they are extremely time-consuming without having as effective results as acetone has.

A very frequently inquired question is that is acetone nail polish remover bad for you. After a lot of discussion among various nail technicians and manufacturers, it was proposed that acetone is the best and most efficient way of removing nail varnish. Also, acetone is not officially declared as a toxic element or something as such, so you can still use it to save your time and energy, along with moisturizing your nails as well as skin afterward.

If you are taking good care of your nails and cuticles after you have used acetone on your nails, there is very little chance that you might be experiencing any serious damage. Also, most nail technicians prefer using acetone and acetone nail polish removers due to their efficient results.
But it is totally up to the user what type of nail polish remover they confide in and feels good to use.

Reference:

The science of nail polishnail polish remover and nail moisturizers

Acetone-free nail polish removers: are they safe?

Nail polish removers: are they harmful?


I write about fashion, style, and nails! I love nail art and have been crafting new styles of doing it for the better part of the 20th century! Fashionkit.com gave me a place to share my passion. Hope you love my work!